Skip to main content

Court affirms trial court's discretion in closing the courtroom during a child witness's testimony

Purvis v. Crosby
2006 WL 1525931 (C.A. 11 (Fla.))
United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit

After being convicted of capital sexual battery on a child under twelve in violation of Florida Statute §794.011 (2)(a); sexual activity with a child twelve years or older by a person in familial or custodial authority using digital penetration in violation of §794.011 (8)(b); and sexual activity with a child twelve years or older using penile union with her vagina, in violation of §794.011 (8)(b); the defendant argued on appeal that his due process rights were violated when the trial judge closed the courtroom to the public during part of the child victim’s testimony and that he was prejudiced by his attorney’s failure to object to the closure.

The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed reasoning as follows:

Closing of the courtroom is appropriate because “although a public trial is a fundamental, constitutional right, the State, in the instant case, was seeking to close the trial in a constitutionally valid manner pursuant to [Fla. Stat] § 987.16,” and “to the extent that there was any error in the trial process itself rather than a structural defect.” This court finds that the trial court ordered a partial closure due to the young age of the victim and the nature of the testimony. The victim’s aunt and uncle were permitted to stay in the courtroom although the record is silent on how many persons stayed in the courtroom or how many persons left the courtroom during the child’s testimony. The defendant’s rights were not violated as his attorney could have objected to the partial closure. However, the attorney’s failure to do so more than likely would not have changed the victim’s testimony in such a way as to create reasonable doubt within the minds of the jurors nor the outcome of the trial. The defendant likewise failed to establish how he was prejudiced by the partial closure or his attorney’s failure to object to the closure.

Popular posts from this blog

Texas State Affairs Committee hears testimony on two adoption bills

On March 27, 2017, Ms. Cochran-Green testified before the Texas Senate State Affairs Committee on two adoption-related bills, SB 329 and
SB 1362.  You can watch the live testimony here. Ms. Cochran-Green's testimony is the Part 1 of the State Affairs Meeting on March 27.  Her testimony is in the second hour and she testified separately on each bill.

SB1362 is authored by Sen. Campbell in which she proposes to changes to the voluntary adoption registry.  Ms. Cochran-Green testified her opposition to the bill because much of the proposed bill is already codified in the Texas Family Code and is common practice among adoption agencies.

SB329 is authored by Senator Creighton in which he proposes to allow adult adopted persons to obtain their original birth certificates at the age of 18.  Ms. Cochran-Green supports this bill as it allows adopted persons in closed adoptions primarily from the 1930s-1990s to seek reunions with their birth parents and obtain medical history that is neede…

Mother's Day: A Time for Reflection and Celebration

This is the time of year that we celebrate motherhood, not only the day-to-day life of being a mom, but also the journey itself.  For some, infertility challenges that journey.  Thankfully there are more options than ever for those who want to become a mother. For many, like myself, the solution was adoption.  I am so thankful for the miracle of adoption, but is it right for you?  The following questions may help you find your answer.
Are you emotionally prepared for adoption? As with making any family planning decision, adoption requires a lot of self-reflection. It also requires that you come to terms with any grief you are experiencing resulting from infertility issues. A friend who adopted told me that she decided to adopt because the chances of becoming a parent were much higher than IVF. That’s true, but there are other challenges to consider. Open adoption is now the norm and it is recommended by experts in the field. Consequently, birth parents will become a part of your famil…

Free Workshop for Divorcees and Widows held in Dripping Springs on Friday, October 14

Jennifer Cochran-Green is hosting a workshop for divorcing and grieving women to approach legal and financial decisions in confidence.  The workshop will  be held  on Friday, October 14, from 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. at the Dripping Springs Community Library at 501 Sportsplex Drive in Dripping Springs. The format is a lunch and learn where light refreshments will be provided and attendees may bring their own lunch if they choose. Jennifer will deliver a presentation focused on issues impacting children immediately after a death of a parent or during divorce.  Leanne Layne, an estate planning attorney with Kernodle Layne Group and Amy Colton, Wealth Advisor with Forefront Wealth Solutions will deliver presentations on making decisions about estate planning and financial issues. 
"I'm so excited to bring this seminar to the Dripping Springs community at no cost to attendees.  Throughout my career, I have found that many women are often caught off guard by their finances when in…