Skip to main content

In the Headlines this Week

What Makes a Man (or Woman) on a Marriage License?         by Brandi Grissom, The Texas Tribune              

In a state that bans same-sex marriage, it would seem to be easy to know who can legally marry. Texas county clerks will tell you it is not.

A two-year-old state law says a court order recognizing a sex or name change is acceptable for marriage license applicants. But a 1999 Texas appeals court ruling stipulates that, at least for purposes of marriage, medical procedures cannot change a person’s gender — you are what you were at birth, period.

This legislative session, politicians have punted on clarifying the issue. And that means that despite the state’s constitutional prohibition of same-sex marriage, some clerks are issuing marriage licenses that, by some definitions, create gay unions. Other clerks are not sure what to do, waiting for lawmakers or the courts to clarify the matter.

“All of that is very unfortunate,” said state Rep. Lois Kolkhorst, R-Brenham, whose 2009 legislation is at the heart of the confusion. Kolkhorst said that at the time, she did not realize her bill would create an issue. “We just didn’t get that clarified and we should,” she said.

Under that law, court orders establishing a change in name or gender are among several documents that can be used for identification purposes in obtaining a marriage license. Other acceptable documents include military IDs, passports, divorce decrees, concealed handgun licenses — even temporary driving permits, among others. But the law does not tell county clerks which of those documents should take precedence in cases where the gender on a person’s birth certificate is different from the one on another document, like a judge’s order.

The El Paso County Clerk’s office faced this conundrum last year. Sabrina Hill was born with both female and male sex organs and identified as a male on her birth certificate. Later, she had gender reassignment procedures and a judge’s order recognized her as a female, as did her driver’s license. When Hill and her partner, Therese Bur, applied for a marriage license, the clerks did not know whether to issue one. Should they use Hill’s original birth certificate and issue a license to the couple? Or should they use the more recent court order and deny the license based on Texas’ constitutional same-sex marriage ban?

The clerk asked Attorney General Greg Abbott what to do, but Abbott declined to opine, deferring to a transgender case making its way through the courts.

In that case, a Wharton County judge ruled on Thursday that the marriage between Nikki Araguz, who was born male but became a female and later married a man, is invalid. Nikki Araguz was married to Thomas Araguz, a Wharton firefighter who died on duty. His family is fighting for his estate, arguing that Nikki Araguz should not receive his money because their marriage was never valid.

That ruling aligns with an appellate court decision that some county clerks, like Gerry Rickhoff in Bexar County, have relied on since 1999. In that case, a conservative court decided that a person’s original birth certificate defines their gender, regardless of subsequent medical procedures. Rickhoff said the court’s ruling is unambiguous, and he grants marriage licenses to couples like Hill and Bur. In fact, after the El Paso County clerk declined to give the couple a marriage license, they went to San Antonio and got one from Rickhoff. “You are what your creator made you,” he said.

Kolkhorst and Sen. Tommy Williams, R-The Woodlands, tried to clear up the issue this session. They filedlegislation that would eliminate court orders recognizing a sex change from the list of acceptable documents for marriage license applicants. Kolkhorst said she does not have an opinion about whether transgender marriage should be legal — her goal was to end the confusion. “At what point does a man become a woman? I don’t know,” she said. “That’s kind of for our creator to decide, not me.”
But the legislation is not expected to pass this year. That leaves the El Paso County clerk and others still confused. “We wouldn’t be able to issue anything until we got legal direction,” said Carol Sagaribay, the El Paso County clerk’s chief deputy. “We would still be in same place.”

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at http://trib.it/mLQH3S.

THE ADVOCATE's NOTE:  Again, the courts are focusing on the case law (another Judge's ruling versus legislation) that your gender is defined AT BIRTH and that if you want to get married, the clerk must refer to your original birth certificate.  In reality, this is impractical and will be difficult to enforce as folks who have had gender reassignment will have their name changed, driver's license, etc. showing that they are no longer the gender they were at birth.  And, it gives sanction to some "gay unions" as noted in my previous post.

Popular posts from this blog

Texas State Affairs Committee hears testimony on two adoption bills

On March 27, 2017, Ms. Cochran-Green testified before the Texas Senate State Affairs Committee on two adoption-related bills, SB 329 and
SB 1362.  You can watch the live testimony here. Ms. Cochran-Green's testimony is the Part 1 of the State Affairs Meeting on March 27.  Her testimony is in the second hour and she testified separately on each bill.

SB1362 is authored by Sen. Campbell in which she proposes changes to the voluntary adoption registry.  Ms. Cochran-Green testified her opposition to the bill as much of the proposed bill is already codified in the Texas Family Code and is common practice among adoption agencies.

SB329 is authored by Senator Creighton in which he proposes to allow adult adopted persons to obtain their original birth certificates at the age of 18.  Ms. Cochran-Green supports this bill as it allows adopted persons in closed adoptions primarily from the 1930s-1990s to seek reunions with their birth parents and obtain medical history that is needed.  This…

Mother's Day: A Time for Reflection and Celebration

This is the time of year that we celebrate motherhood, not only the day-to-day life of being a mom, but also the journey itself.  For some, infertility challenges that journey.  Thankfully there are more options than ever for those who want to become a mother. For many, like myself, the solution was adoption.  I am so thankful for the miracle of adoption, but is it right for you?  The following questions may help you find your answer.
Are you emotionally prepared for adoption? As with making any family planning decision, adoption requires a lot of self-reflection. It also requires that you come to terms with any grief you are experiencing resulting from infertility issues. A friend who adopted told me that she decided to adopt because the chances of becoming a parent were much higher than IVF. That’s true, but there are other challenges to consider. Open adoption is now the norm and it is recommended by experts in the field. Consequently, birth parents will become a part of your famil…

Documents Every Graduating Senior and College Student Needs

Now that high school graduation is upon us, it’s a time for celebration and reflection for parents and students alike. For parents, you now face the fact that your little bird is leaving the nest.  Is he or she ready? Legally, they are adults now and entitled to privacy protections. This means that even though your child may be relying on your financial support, privacy laws prohibit financial institutions, medical providers and colleges from disclosing private information concerning your child unless authorized. In case of an emergency, your child needs the following documents in place for you to be able to help them and make decisions on their behalf:
  1. Durable Power of Attorney: This document allows you to manage their financial affairs (either immediately or in the future) should they travel abroad or become mentally or physically unable to do so. This includes managing their financial accounts,  renewing their car registration, or filing a tax return on their behalf.
  2. Medica…